| Club Domestic | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Premier League | Winner | 7x | 1980/1981, 1909/1910, 1899/1900, 1898/1899, 1896/1897, 1895/1896, 1893/1894 |
| Runner-up | 10x | 1992/1993, 1989/1990, 1932/1933, 1930/1931, 1913/1914, 1912/1913, 1910/1911, 1907/1908, 1902/1903, 1888/1889 | |
| Championship | Winner | 2x | 1959/1960, 1937/1938 |
| Runner-up | 2x | 1987/1988, 1974/1975 | |
| FA Cup | Winner | 7x | 1956/1957, 1919/1920, 1912/1913, 1904/1905, 1896/1897, 1894/1895, 1886/1887 |
| Runner-up | 4x | 2014/2015, 1999/2000, 1923/1924, 1891/1892 | |
| League Cup | Winner | 5x | 1995/1996, 1993/1994, 1976/1977, 1974/1975, 1960/1961 |
| Runner-up | 4x | 2019/2020, 2009/2010, 1970/1971, 1962/1963 | |
| Community Shield | Winner | 1x | 1981/1982 |
| Runner-up | 3x | 1972/1973, 1957/1958, 1910/1911 | |
| Club International | |||
| UEFA Champions League | Winner | 1x | 1981/1982 |
| UEFA Super Cup | Winner | 1x | 1982/1983 |
| Queensland Champions Cup | Winner | 1x | 2022 |
| Inter Continental Cup | Runner-up | 1x | 1982 |
